Chapter 1: Chapter One: The Letter
Noah Carter had never liked coming home.
Willow Creek was the kind of town where nothing ever seemed to change—where everyone knew your name, and your business, and where the same coffee shop still served the best cinnamon rolls on Main Street. It felt like a place stuck in time, where everyone lived on repeat, and no one ever moved on. For Noah, coming back always felt like stepping into a place that never really understood him.
He kicked the gravel on his way up the driveway to his grandmother's house, the familiar sound of it crunching under his sneakers almost as nostalgic as the old house itself. The porch swing creaked with the wind as he walked up the steps, the paint chipped from years of weather. The smell of something baking—probably cookies or fresh bread—drifted through the air, and his stomach grumbled. Grandma Ellen had always been big on homemade treats, even if she was getting slower at making them these days.
"You look exhausted, kid," Grandma Ellen said, stepping out onto the porch before he could even knock, her voice raspy but warm.
Noah forced a smile. "Just a long drive," he replied, his tone flat. He wasn't sure why he always felt so awkward around her, but it was probably because he hadn't seen her in over a year.
"Longer years," she said, her gaze sharp but soft at the same time. "I'm glad you're here."
He nodded, though "here" didn't feel much like home anymore. The town was too small, too quiet, too full of memories he wasn't ready to confront. But he didn't have a choice.
Later that evening, when Grandma Ellen had gone to bed, Noah found himself wandering through the house, unsure of what he was looking for. The place hadn't changed in forever—same dusty bookshelves, same old furniture that had been there since he was a kid. He moved through the house in a haze, each room reminding him of things he couldn't quite shake off. The sound of his sneakers on the hardwood floor echoed in the silence. It was the same silence that always made him feel trapped here.
He ended up in the study, a small room tucked at the back of the house. The smell of old paper hit him immediately. He ran a hand along the bookshelves, glancing over the spines of books his parents used to read to him when he was younger. Nothing seemed to catch his eye, until his fingers brushed against an old, leather-bound Bible—his mom's Bible. The one she'd kept on her nightstand before the accident. It was worn, the edges soft from years of use, the gold lettering on the cover faded.
For some reason, Noah felt a pull. He flipped it open, and a yellowed envelope slipped out from between the pages, landing with a soft thud on the desk. His brow furrowed. It wasn't unusual for him to find old letters or notes in his mom's books, but this one felt different. The paper was fragile, almost like it might disintegrate in his hands. His fingers carefully unfolded the letter, revealing the faded ink of the handwriting.
"The hidden light is near. Trust in the Lord, and you will find it."
It was signed by his dad.
Noah froze. His dad had passed away in a car crash when he was just six, and to be honest, he didn't remember much about him—just bits and pieces, like flashes of a movie he couldn't quite piece together. The whole thing had always felt weird. His parents' death was a mystery that no one talked about, like it was something no one was brave enough to confront.
So why had no one ever mentioned this letter? And what did it mean?
Noah sat down in the chair at the desk, his heart hammering in his chest. His fingers tightened around the paper. His dad had been gone for over a decade, but somehow, this felt like a message from the past, something that was supposed to stay hidden but had found its way back to him.
His mind raced. "The hidden light"? It sounded like something out of a mystery novel. Was it just some cryptic note, or was it a clue to something bigger?
A name flashed in his mind: Pastor Grace Dawson.
Grace Chapel had been the place his parents used to go, and even now, Grace Dawson was the one person in town who might understand what the message meant. She'd taken over the church after his parents' death, and she was only a few years older than Noah. People respected her, and from what he'd heard, she always seemed to know what was going on in people's lives. If anyone had answers, it would be her.
Noah folded the letter carefully and slipped it into his hoodie pocket. He wasn't sure what he was looking for, but something told him that whatever his dad had left behind… it wasn't meant to stay buried.
The next morning, Noah woke up early, the sunlight filtering in through the old curtains of the guest room. It had been a restless night, his thoughts too tangled around the letter to get much sleep. He couldn't shake the feeling that whatever his dad had written was important—important enough to lead him to something, maybe even to the truth about his parents' death.
He had to find Pastor Grace. He had to find out what the letter meant.
Noah grabbed his hoodie, stuffing his phone and the letter into his pockets, and slipped out of the house without waking Grandma Ellen. He didn't know what to expect, but he wasn't ready to sit around waiting for answers.
The walk to Grace Chapel was short, but each step felt heavier. The town was still sleepy, the roads empty except for a few parked cars. He passed the old diner where he used to meet his friends on weekends—except they'd all moved on, left for bigger cities, better opportunities. He had stayed behind, unable to escape the pull of his past.
When he reached the chapel, the tall, stone building stood in front of him like a silent witness to all the secrets that had been buried here. The doors were locked, but through the windows, he could see Grace's figure moving inside. He took a deep breath and knocked softly on the door.
A few moments passed before it creaked open, and there she was—Grace Dawson. Her blonde hair was pulled into a messy ponytail, her eyes warm but cautious as she met his gaze.
"Noah Carter," she said with a small smile. "What brings you here?"
"I... I need your help," he said, his voice unsteady. He pulled the letter out of his pocket and handed it to her. "I found this. It's from my dad."
Grace took the letter and read it, her expression unreadable. For a long moment, she didn't say anything. Noah's stomach churned with uncertainty. Finally, she looked up at him, her eyes thoughtful.
"You've come for the truth, haven't you?" she asked quietly.
Noah nodded. "I need to know what happened to them. I need to understand."
She stepped aside, gesturing for him to come in. "We'll figure this out together."